All guides

Solar System · 3 min read

Why is Pluto not a planet?

On 24 August 2006, at a meeting in Prague, the International Astronomical Union voted on the first official definition of a planet. Pluto, a planet since its discovery in 1930, did not meet it and became a “dwarf planet”.

The decision was less sudden than it seemed. It came after more than a decade of discoveries that made Pluto look less like a lone planet and more like one member of a crowd.

Updated

The three tests

Under the 2006 definition, a planet is a body that:

  • orbits the Sun;
  • is massive enough that its own gravity has pulled it into a round shape;
  • has “cleared the neighbourhood” around its orbit, meaning it is by far the dominant body there.

Pluto passes the first two and fails the third. It shares its region of space with thousands of other icy bodies in the Kuiper belt, and its orbit even crosses Neptune’s. Earth, by comparison, outweighs everything else near its orbit many thousands of times over. A round body that fails only the third test is a dwarf planet.

It had happened before

When Giuseppe Piazzi found Ceres in 1801, it was hailed as the missing planet between Mars and Jupiter. Within a few years three more were found in the same region, and by the 1850s there were dozens. Astronomers stopped calling them planets and started calling them asteroids. Pluto’s story repeated this, a century and a half later.

What changed: the Kuiper belt and Eris

Pluto was always odd. It is smaller than seven moons, including our own, and has only about a sixth of the Moon’s mass. Its orbit is tilted and stretched compared with the other planets.

In 1992 David Jewitt and Jane Luu found a small icy body beyond Neptune, the first known member of the Kuiper belt apart from Pluto and its moon. Hundreds more followed. Then in 2005 Mike Brown’s team announced Eris, almost exactly as wide as Pluto and more massive. Astronomers had a choice: make Eris the tenth planet, and probably accept dozens more as they were found, or draw a line that left Pluto out.

The argument has not ended

Only 424 astronomers voted, on the last day of the meeting, out of a membership of about 10,000. Many planetary scientists, including Alan Stern, who led the New Horizons mission to Pluto, reject the definition. They argue that what a world is like should matter more than what is near it, and that any body massive enough to be round should count as a planet. By that rule the Solar System would have well over a hundred planets, including large moons such as our own.

Supporters say the definition captures a real difference: the eight planets formed by sweeping up their regions of the young Solar System, and the dwarf planets did not.

What New Horizons found

Whatever it is called, Pluto turned out to be far more interesting than expected. When New Horizons flew past in July 2015, it found a plain of nitrogen ice about 1,000 km wide with no craters, so it must be young; mountains of water ice several kilometres high; and a thin atmosphere with layers of blue haze. Its largest moon, Charon, is half its width.

Five dwarf planets are recognised today: Ceres, Pluto, Eris, Haumea and Makemake. Several more Kuiper belt objects are probably large enough to qualify.

More guides